After the Softwood Lumber Ruling, What Can Canada Do?
A B.C. sawmill operator faces a bigger duty bill for past shipments even as deposits fall on new ones. Where can Canadian mills find relief?
Canada already taxes some American lumber. Its mills also need buyers beyond the United States, more orders at home and a workable deal with Washington.
On November 5, Western Forest Products said it expected its Cowichan Bay and Chemainus sawmills to remain under curtailment through the end of 2026. It cited weak markets, high U.S. duties and tariffs, and operating conditions in British Columbia. The next day, a NAFTA Chapter 19 panel upheld a revised U.S. anti-dumping determination. Global Affairs Canada says the ruling effectively ends the challenge to the original 2017 finding.
The separate October duty reviews show why relief is complicated. Western reported that its combined anti-dumping and countervailing rate for new shipments fell from 35.16 per cent to 24.75 per cent. The final rates on its 2024 shipments came in above what it had deposited at the time. In the same quarterly results, under “Softwood Lumber Dispute”, the company said it expected to record a US$27.6-million non-cash expense plus about US$5.5 million in accrued interest.
Is Canadian lumber unfairly subsidized?
The U.S. Lumber Coalition says Canadian producers are subsidized. A central question is what they pay for timber. Provinces charge a fee, called stumpage, for the right to harvest trees on public land. The U.S. argument is that some of those fees are below what comparable timber would fetch in a competitive market, giving Canadian producers a cost advantage. The U.S. Commerce Department found countervailable subsidies in its October review, which covered 2024 shipments.
Canada disputes that its timber pricing amounts to a subsidy. B.C. auctions about one-fifth of the provincial harvest and uses the bids to help set what other licence holders pay. Canada’s argument is that the comparison should start with local market evidence and count the full cost of getting the timber. Tree species, quality, and obligations such as building roads and replanting matter. The U.S. Congressional Research Service called the evidence inconclusive on whether Canadian tenure fees are below market production costs.
A WTO panel found in 2020 that U.S. Commerce failed to adequately explain why it rejected several Canadian price comparisons, including B.C. auction prices. It also found Commerce had failed to adequately adjust Washington State log prices before using them to value B.C. standing timber. The U.S. appealed, and the case remains pending. In a separate proceeding under U.S. law, an October 2026 NAFTA panel upheld Commerce’s revised subsidy finding from the original investigation. Commerce amended the original rates in November, leaving newer deposit rates in place for firms already covered by later reviews. The November 6 ruling addressed whether Canadian lumber was sold below what U.S. trade law calls normal value.
The duties protect U.S. mills from Canadian competition. Washington’s separate Section 232 tariff applies on national-security grounds, independently of the subsidy finding. Whether a specific timber program gives a Canadian producer an unfair advantage depends on what comparable trees would sell for under comparable conditions. The U.S. has a legal finding for the programs it examined. Canada has documented reasons to challenge how Washington calculated the alleged advantage.
Where Canadian mills can sell more
Start with the countries already buying Canadian lumber. In 2025, the United States took 75 per cent of B.C.’s softwood lumber export volume. China, including Hong Kong and Macau in the provincial data, took 10 per cent and Japan took 7 per cent. Those figures come from Table 5 of B.C.’s year-end export report. They show where mills already have customers and how much business would have to move to replace even part of the U.S. market.
Japan offers a concrete example of how to sell more. Its authorities recognized revised structural design values for Canadian hem-fir lumber, which helps builders specify it. Canadian mills should work with importers in Japan and China to identify grades, dimensions and volumes buyers will commit to, then price the order with freight included. South Korea is also a market B.C. is cultivating. It makes sense to pursue specific building-product orders there. Before mills spend money changing production, they need to know who will take delivery and at what price.
Where Canadian counter-tariffs help
Canada already applies a 25-per-cent surtax to listed U.S.-origin sawn softwood, including spruce-pine-fir. Selected plywood and laminated veneer lumber face 50 per cent. Those measures took effect September 8 in response to broader U.S. tariffs under Sections 338 and 232. The November panel ruling concerns a different U.S. measure.
Ottawa should consider widening the list only where Canadian mills can supply the same product, in the required grade and quantity, at a workable delivered price. Where buyers can switch, the surtax can shift orders to Canadian suppliers. Where they can’t, Canadian builders and manufacturers may simply pay more. That risk is already visible in the federal remission list, which includes narrowly specified items such as certain structural laminated veneer lumber. Any wider measure should come with a review date, a way to seek relief for genuine shortages and a clear demand at the negotiating table.
What Canada can do at home and at the negotiating table
Canadian builders and retailers can ask suppliers where their lumber was milled and switch orders where a Canadian product meets the same specification, price and delivery window. Public buyers can do the same at a larger scale. Ottawa’s Buy Canadian materials policy already covers Canadian wood on qualifying federal projects. For construction, it generally applies to contracts of at least $25 million when the wood portion is expected to reach $250,000, subject to exceptions. Provinces and municipalities could check supply before putting housing and other construction projects out to tender, then publish how much Canadian wood the winning contracts will actually buy.
For mills facing a temporary slowdown, BDC-backed financing can help with cash flow, while Work-Sharing can provide income support to eligible employees on temporarily reduced hours. Ottawa should judge its proposed forest-sector investment by whether mills can fill new orders, Canadian projects buy their wood and shifts return or stay in place.
A negotiated agreement is still worth pursuing. The U.S. homebuilders’ association wants the tariffs removed, arguing they raise building costs. Canada should work with American buyers who need reliable supply and seek a deal that lowers trade duties, addresses the separate Section 232 tariff and spells out how existing deposits would be handled. The next U.S. duty reviews cover 2025 shipments, and Ottawa should keep defending Canadian producers in those proceedings. In Cowichan Bay and Chemainus, the result people can measure is whether the mills have enough work to put shifts back on the schedule.