NASTYCANUCK.CA POLITE · PERSISTENT · PROUDLY CANADIAN

Explainers

Who Pays When Someone Breaks Into Your Bank Account?

A disputed transfer can leave a bank customer waiting for answers. Here’s what the law provides today and what Ottawa’s anti-fraud plan could change.

A bank statement with one transaction highlighted in amber lies beside a smartphone displaying a notification on a kitchen table.
Illustration: Nasty Canuck / AI-assisted.

Ottawa is proposing a $0 liability cap for losses from unauthorized account access. How the money moved could determine what protection a customer gets.

In 2019, a retired bank customer clicked a link in a text that appeared to offer a refund, then called her bank when something seemed wrong. That evening she learned that someone she didn’t know had accepted a $3,000 e-transfer from her account. The bank investigated and initially declined to reimburse her. The Ombudsman for Banking Services and Investments found that the bank should have offered to put a hold on the account when she first called. It recommended reimbursing the full amount. The bank agreed and the customer accepted its offer.

That case shows what can turn on a decision made before the money moves. Under Finance Canada’s November 6 anti-fraud proposal, a Bank Act amendment would cap a customer’s liability at $0 for transactions resulting from unauthorized access across all types of accounts they hold with a bank. The proposed exception is gross negligence by the customer, called gross fault in Québec.

Who sent the money?

A scam can end with the customer sending the payment themselves. In another case published by the ombudsman, a woman authorized transfers to buy cryptocurrency and sent it to what she believed were investment firms. Her bank warned her that it might be a scam. She ultimately lost $52,600. The ombudsman’s approach to fraud complaints distinguishes payments a customer approved from payments made without their authorization.

For a customer who sent the money after being deceived, the question is whether a separate part of Finance Canada’s proposal could help. It would require banks, telecom providers and digital platforms covered by the framework to provide redress when breaking the proposed rules can be directly tied to a fraud loss. The draft legislation will need to show how a customer could establish that connection.

What you can do today

If you see a transaction you didn’t authorize, report it to your financial institution right away. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada says federally regulated institutions must investigate and consider all relevant factors before finding you at fault. For chequing and savings accounts, the agency says you usually have 30 days from the date of your statement to dispute a transaction. Check your account agreement for the deadline that applies to you.

For credit cards issued in Canada, the Bank Act already sets a $50 maximum for unauthorized use, subject to its gross-negligence exception, or gross fault in Québec. The Act sets liability at zero for unauthorized use after the institution receives a report that the card or its related information has been lost, stolen or put at risk.

If you file a complaint with a bank, it has 56 calendar days from when you first complained to provide a detailed written response. You can take an unresolved complaint to the ombudsman after that period, or sooner if the bank provides its detailed written response and closes your file.

Finance Canada plans to consult on draft legislation in 2027 and aims to introduce final legislation before the end of that year. When the text arrives, look for who must prove gross negligence, what records a customer can get from the bank and whether the legislation sets a deadline for returning the money after a claim is accepted. Those details will matter to someone staring at a missing $3,000.