> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.nastycanuck.ca/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Where Canada Fits in the Commonwealth’s Reparations Debate
- URL: https://www.nastycanuck.ca/commonwealth-slavery-reparations-canada/
- Published: 2026-11-07T03:35:21.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-08T01:47:13.000Z
- Description: CARICOM’s proposal covers a formal apology, health and education, and the return of cultural heritage.
- Author: Nasty Canuck Editorial Desk
- Tags: Explainers, Canadian Corner, Commonwealth, Foreign Policy

*Commonwealth leaders welcomed Britain’s offer of talks in Antigua. Canada had abstained on a United Nations resolution the summit cited.*

Before the leaders met in Antigua, British Prime Minister Andy Burnham [wrote that he was open to a formal apology](https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/oct/30/british-people-slave-trade-reparations-andy-burnham) for Britain’s role in the transatlantic slave trade. He opposed financial reparations, arguing that they would hold people in Britain today liable for historical wrongs. Saint Lucia’s prime minister, Philip J. Pierre, speaking as chair of the Caribbean Community, [welcomed the offer of talks](https://caricom.org/statement-from-the-chair-of-the-caribbean-community-hon-philip-j-pierre-prime-minister-of-saint-lucia-reparatory-justice-31-october-2026/) and asked Britain to discuss the full Caribbean proposal, including compensation.

## What the Caribbean wants discussed

Pierre put the responsibility on governments and institutions. When Britain abolished slavery in most of its empire, the government [paid about £20 million to slaveholders](https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/-/media/boe/files/museum/slavery-and-the-bank-large-print-guide.pdf). The people who had been enslaved received no compensation. For Pierre, that history helps explain why an apology from the British state would matter and why he wants it to come with commitments to repair the harm.

The Caribbean Community, known as CARICOM, spells out what that repair could involve in its [revised Ten-Point Plan](https://caricom.org/wp-content/uploads/CARICOM%5FReparationsManifesto-D%5F260617%5F104759.pdf). It calls for the return of cultural objects to their places of origin and for funding to sustain Caribbean cultural institutions. The plan describes what that would mean for a schoolchild or a researcher in the region. They could learn from objects that have long been held in European collections. Other proposals include funding for medical research and investment in digital technology and infrastructure for education.

Pierre also welcomed the prospect of debt relief. He pointed out that most CARICOM countries are classified as middle- or high-income and routinely miss out on favourable financing. A country can clear an income threshold and still struggle to borrow on affordable terms after a hurricane. Pierre wants vulnerability taken into account in any debt initiative and sees debt relief as one part of a wider package.

## How the talks could work

At their 2024 summit in Samoa, Commonwealth leaders had called for a conversation about reparatory justice. The [November 4 Commonwealth communiqué](https://comsec-web-static.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/s3fs-public/2026-11/CHOGM-2026-Communique-Nov2026.pdf#page=15) went a step further. It welcomed Britain’s agreement to structured, time-limited talks with affected parties about the trafficking of enslaved Africans and the harms it caused.

[Ghana’s account of a meeting with Britain’s foreign secretary](https://mfa.gov.gh/index.php/ghana-uk-bilateral-meeting-focused-on-progress-towards-establishing-a-structured-dialogue-on-reparatory-justice/) gives some idea of how the talks might work. The ministers discussed African and Caribbean co-chairs and a proposed 12-month process. Ghana listed education, the return of cultural objects and debt among the possible topics. The two ministers wanted to settle the terms by the end of 2026\. Those terms will set out who takes part and what the talks cover. Whether compensation makes it onto the agenda is still open.

## Where Canada fits

Ghana also led the United Nations resolution cited in the Antigua communiqué. The resolution described the trafficking and enslavement of Africans as the gravest crime against humanity. It passed in March with 123 votes in favour. [Canada was among 52 countries that abstained](https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4106660). A [joint explanation from Canada and Australia](https://estatements.un.org/estatements/10.0010/20260331150000000/zMmtrKzhGVfK/fMBoB-%5FX%5Fnyc%5Fen.pdf), posted in the UN archive and marked as a draft, objects to language that could rank crimes against humanity. It also expresses support for dialogue on reparatory justice.

Prime Minister Mark Carney [met with Caribbean leaders at the summit](https://www.pm.gc.ca/en/news/news-releases/2026/11/03/prime-minister-carney-deepens-partnerships-commonwealth-nations). Ottawa’s account of that meeting describes talks on energy, food security, infrastructure and disaster preparedness under the Canada–CARICOM partnership. At the summit, Carney also announced more than $70 million for projects across the Commonwealth, including in the Caribbean, to help with work such as emergency preparedness and infrastructure.

Canada has its own history of slavery. [Parks Canada documents the enslavement of people of African descent](https://parks.canada.ca/culture/designation/evenement-event/esclavage-enslavement) in British and French colonies that became Quebec, Ontario and parts of Atlantic Canada. An Upper Canada law passed in 1793 restricted the bringing in of enslaved people and left those already enslaved in bondage. British abolition took effect in 1834\. The provisions compensating slaveholders did not apply in the colonies of British North America.

## A different request at home

The [previous instalment](https://www.nastycanuck.ca/canada-commonwealth-colonial-history/) ended with a separate request addressed directly to Ottawa. The Truth and Reconciliation Commission’s [Call to Action 45](https://nctr.ca/about/truth-and-reconciliation-commission-of-canada-calls-to-action/) asks the federal government and Indigenous peoples to develop a Royal Proclamation of Reconciliation together for the Crown to issue. The commission proposed that it renew treaty relationships and recognize Indigenous laws and legal traditions in negotiations over treaties and land claims.

Ottawa’s [progress report](https://rcaanc-cirnac.gc.ca/eng/1524503097736/1557513982301) points to a 2021 law on implementing the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples and an action plan developed with First Nations, Inuit and Métis. [Indigenous Watchdog lists Call 45 as not started](https://www.indigenouswatchdog.org/cta/call-to-action-45/). The federal report tracks work on individual commitments. The watchdog is looking for a process to bring them together in the proclamation the commission called for.

---

**Editor’s note:** This is the third instalment of *Canada and the Commonwealth: Past, Purpose and Possibility*. The series opened with [What Does Canada Actually Get from the Commonwealth?](https://www.nastycanuck.ca/canada-commonwealth-membership-value/). The next planned instalment looks at what Canada and its Commonwealth partners can do together today in trade, education and research, and what might stand in the way.